Membership & Fellowship: Paying Off Medical School Loans—What Every Doctor Needs to Know

Originally published on the SoFi online blog.

Most people think that doctors have it pretty easy when it comes to paying off medical student loans. Sure, they rack up six figures worth of student debt—but their outsized salaries should help them decimate those loans in no time (not to mention set them up for life).

However, if you’re a doctor, you know the reality of having medical school loans is more complicated than people might think. For one thing, you don’t start making “student loan payoff money” until you’re out of residency, which—depending on your focus—can take three, four, five, or even 10 years. During that time, you have to juggle a big student loan balance with a relatively small paycheck, learn the nuances of various medical school loan repayment programs, and stay on top of changing student loan legislation that can impact your payments or potential student loan forgiveness.

It’s challenges like this that inspired Jim Dahle, MD, FACEP, to launch his popular blog, The White Coat Investor, six years ago. After a string of bad experiences with financial professionals, Dahle realized that doctors need resources and education customized to their specific financial challenges. “I watch doctors make the same money mistakes I made over and over again,” says Dahle, whose site receives nearly 600,000 views per month from doctors seeking financial information relevant to them.

The White Coat Investor covers a variety of topics, but the subject of medical student loans is always in rotation. SoFi asked Dr. Dahle to share what he thinks every doctor should know about paying off medical school loans.

Q: Why is paying off medical school debt more complicated than people think?

A: Up until a few years ago, the options for doctors with student debt were fairly limited. You used income-based repayment (IBR) to make lower payments on federal loans during residency, then when you got out, you made full payments until your debt was done—and that was that. Your biggest decision was whether or not to work for a 501(c)(3) organization in order to take advantage of Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), where your federal loans are forgiven after 10 years.

But today there are a number of options for med school borrowers, and each choice affects how much you’ll spend on interest, how quickly you’ll pay off loans and whether your loans can be forgiven. Also, some of these variables are affected by student loan legislation, which is constantly evolving. It’s a lot for doctors to stay on top of.

Q: How have things changed?

A: A few years ago, companies like SoFi came on the scene and offered the option to refinance student loans, both private and federal. Doctors coming out of residency could cut the rate on their loans and save a significant amount on interest. But the decision was still pretty simple—you’d either stay in IBR and go for PSLF or you’d apply to refinance federal loans (refinancing private loans is usually a no-brainer either way).

Then, some lenders started to offer refinancing for medical residents* banking on their eventual increase in income. This moved up the decision point for refinancing, because if you’re not planning to use PSLF, you may as well refinance and start saving money as early as possible.

But in 2015, the government expanded its income-driven repayment program with the launch of REPAYE (Revised Pay As You Earn). Under REPAYE, the government forgives up to 50 percent of interest accrued on loans while in the program, which dramatically lowers the effective interest rate for residents—lower than the typical refinance rate. So now, medical residents have to weigh PSLF, refinancing and REPAYE when making decisions about student loans.

Q: You emphasize PSLF, but what about getting loan forgiveness through REPAYE or the other income-driven repayment plans?

A: These plans don’t make sense for most doctors after residency because their income is too high—you’d have to be a really low paid doctor and/or have a massive debt load for the payment discount to work, and you only get the loan forgiveness after 20-25 years in the program. Most docs have paid their debt off well before then.

Q: How common is it for doctors to qualify for public loan forgiveness?

There are tons of jobs that qualify—if you work in academia, a nonprofit hospital, public health, the military, etc. It’s not for everyone, but it’s not a small number—I would estimate that 15-20 percent of MD positions are considered 501(c)(3) and therefore eligible for PSLF. In some areas, it may even be a majority of positions.

Q: How does student loan legislation affect medical school loan repayment programs and forgiveness options?

A: Besides the REPAYE example, the biggest thing to keep an eye on is legislation around public loan forgiveness. Starting in 2017, the first participants in the program will see their loans forgiven (after 10 years of consecutive payments while working in a public service profession). Soon after, I imagine we’ll start seeing headlines like “Doctors Receive $400,000 in Loan Forgiveness at Taxpayers’ Expense.” I don’t know how many stories like that will have to run before the government changes the program.

Now, if they do make changes, will they grandfather in the current participants? I would hope so, and there’s precedent for that, but there are no guarantees. My best guess is that the program won’t last forever, at least not in its current state. The Obama administration already proposed a $57,000 cap two years ago, which would’ve made it a non-starter for most doctors.

Q: What’s the biggest financial mistake you see doctors make?

A: It’s not any one mistake, necessarily, just a lot of the same ones. Most doctors grow into their income too fast. They get a huge income bump after residency and don’t have a plan for how to spend and invest it wisely.

For example, if you can continue to live on a lower budget for a couple of years after your post-residency pay increase, you could make a huge dent in your debt and set yourself up for greater financial success. It may not be the most appealing option, but in the long term, it can have a big payoff.

ACOG has partnered with SoFi to bring members and their families the opportunity to save on student loan debt. If you or your family have medical school debt, you can refinance your student and Parent PLUS loans through to receive a 0.125% rate discount1.

*SoFi has a Medical Resident and Fellow Refinancing Program. If you have less than four years left of your fellowship program, you can apply to refinance and pay a minimum of $100/month2. Accrued interest does not compound while paying $100/month2. This means that you don’t accrue interest while in your fellowship program. Fellows who refinance through also receive the 0.125% rate discount1.

Terms and Conditions Apply. SOFI RESERVES THE RIGHT TO MODIFY OR DISCONTINUE PRODUCTS AND BENEFITS AT ANY TIME WITHOUT NOTICE. SoFi refinance loans are private loans and do not have the same repayment options that the federal loan program offers such as Income Based Repayment or Income Contingent Repayment or PAYE. SoFi loans not offered to residents of Nevada. Other state restrictions may apply. See eligibility requirements at Licensed by the Department of Business Oversight under the California Finance Lender Law License No. 6054612. SoFi loans are originated by SoFi Lending Corp., NMLS # 1121636.

1Rate discount will be issued electronically once you become a SoFi borrower; you have submitted a completed application with documents and your loan has been disbursed. Offer good for new customers only. 2Though interest does not compound during residency, interest still accrues. Additionally, the minimum monthly payment of $100 while in residency may not pay all the interest due each month, which will likely result in a negative amortization.

American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
409 12th Street SW, Washington, DC  20024-2188
Mailing Address: PO Box 96920, Washington, DC 20024-9998